BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND TWITTER BACKGROUNDS »

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Philosophy of Religion Paper Part 3

There are five key challenges to the structure of the above argument. The first is the incoherent idea of instrumental evil. Evil that is instrumental as a means to an end is not really evil. It may be called a trial. It may be called suffering. But if it brings about a positive end result, it cannot be considered evil. The word evil has nine definitions that relate to it in the Webster dictionary. They range from definitions as benign as disagreeable to as strong as wickedness. The nature of the above argument can be thwarted by a simple discussion on the use of the word evil. This challenge also only affects the category of natural evil, because the category of moral evil may have results that do not lead to a positive end.

Another objection is the idea of counter-productive evil. This would be evil that leads to soul-destroying. There are two counter-arguments that can be used to foil this objection. The first is, once again, the inclusion of the category of moral evil produced by significantly free beings. It is not specified for the purpose of soul-making, it is merely the effect of actions taken by significantly free beings. The second is the idea that the process of soul-making is a test and that to satisfy the stipulation of significantly free beings, the test must allow for failure. It is intrinsic to the idea of free-will that one is given moments in which one has the opportunity to fail. These moments also extend from the stance that there must be opposition in all things. If there is no chance at failure, there is also no real chance at success.

The third opposing argument is a problem with the economy of evil. It seems that for soul-building, God, being omnibenevolent, would only allow for the minimal amount necessary. The amount present in the world seems excessive. There even seems to be a disproportionate ratio between good and evil, favoring the evil. Examples of excessive natural evil can be seen in the destruction of natural disasters or epidemic illnesses. Examples of excessive moral evil can include the actions of figures like Hitler, Stalin, and Mao Tse Tung. It is in thinking about these examples that the amount of evil evident in the world can seem overwhelming. It is difficult to know what is truly excessive in the eyes of God. The excessive evil may also be caused by moral evil that stems from the actions of significantly free beings. It can be difficult to comprehend why God would allow for so much evil, but it is in this instance that the transcendence of God must be used to refute such an argument. Only God is omniscient, and so it is impossible for a human being to be able to fully comprehend all the information that may be relevant to this discussion.

The fourth objection is similar in nature to the above argument; it is the idea of pointless-evil. William Rowe presented an argument for this objection in his paper “The Problem of Evil and Some Varieties of Atheism”. He reiterated the objection in a more recent paper titled, “Friendly Atheism, Skeptical Theism, and the Problem of Evil”. His argument focuses on the nature of pointless evil seen in the natural suffering of animals. He use the example of a fawn caught in a natural forest fire, is severely burnt, and suffers for five days before dying. Rowe draws the counter-argument below from out of this example.
1. Probably, there are pointless evils. (e.g., the fawn’s suffering).
2. If God exists, there are no pointless evils, therefore,
3. Probably, God does not exist.

The most common response to this follows along the same line as the response to the unequal economy of evil. God is omniscient, and it is injudicious for human beings to classify the evil in the world in this way because human beings do not have access to all the information that may be pertinent to the situation. It can also be flipped in the same way that Leibniz flipped Mackie’s argument.
1. Probably, God exists.
2. If God exists, there are no pointless evils, therefore,
3. Probably, there are no pointless evils.
This effectually shows the problematic nature of such an argument. The logical process proves two very different things based on the premises one subscribes to as true.

The final objection focuses on the idea that God could have created free beings that always choose right. This argument is contradictory in nature. Plantinga refutes this argument in his version of the free-will defense. He begins by showing that God is limited in creation or actualization by certain properties, because just as the beginning of God seems absurd so does the beginning of something like the color red. “Properties are not creatable: to suppose that they have been created is to suppose that although they exist now, there was a time at which they did not; and this seems clearly false.” It is possible that freedom could be one of these properties, and if such is the case, it is a property that may limit the nature of actualization or creation by God.
This world could be a result of that logical limitation. Plantinga shows the illogical nature of a world with significantly free beings that God created to always choose right. “If God brings it about that I refrain from A, then I do not freely refrain from A.” This objection is refuted by its contradictory nature.

The problem of evil is best contested by an argument that combines elements of John Hick’s soul-making theodicy and Alvin Plantinga’s free-will defense. The combination of these two philosophies with the added support of the theory of opposition, form a solid defense against and explanation for the problem of evil. John Hick shows that this world is in the process of becoming the best possible world. The process is necessary because the best possible world contains human beings that must necessarily progress. This progression can account for both the natural and moral evil seen in this world. The natural evil is a test that builds their souls. The moral evil is a result of the significantly free nature of human beings. This process and its consequences are exemplified in the story of Adam and Eve. Evil plays an essential role in the nature of this world and can only be understood through the lens of soul-making, free-will, and opposition.

Friday, December 11, 2009

Philosophy of Religion Paper Part 2

A logical question stemming from Plantinga’s proposition is, “Why is a world containing significantly free creatures, better than a world with creatures that are compelled to always choose right?” The answer to this question can best be established by John Hick’s soul-making theodicy. Hick answers this question by explaining, “that one who has attained goodness by meeting and eventually mastering temptations, and thus by rightly making responsible choices in concrete situations, is good in a richer and more valuable sense than would be one created ab initio (from the beginning) in a state of either innocence or virtue.” (definition in parenthesis added) (1) Hick use the parent/child relationship to illustrate this point. “Certainly we seek pleasure for our children, and take great delight in obtaining it for them; but we do not desire for them unalloyed pleasure at the expense of their growth in such even greater values.” (2) The contrast between pleasure and values of a higher standard is set. God can be understood as a loving Heavenly Father who wants the best for the creatures he created. To help his creatures become the best or to create the best possible world, there is a process involved and that process can involve a variety of evils. Hick’s theodicy places value on natural evils as a way to build ones soul, where Plantinga’s free-will defense helps us to understand the foundation of moral evil as a result of significantly free creatures.

Combining the philosophical views of Plantinga and Hick, one creates a solid line of defense and explanation against the problem of evil.

1. If God exists, then God would be omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent.
2. An omnipotent being could bring about any logically possible world.
3. An omnibenevolent being would want to bring about the best possible world.
4. Humans that meet and master temptation are better than those that are in a state of innocence or virtue from the beginning.
5. The best logically possible world than is one that requires the progression of the human beings within it.
6. The progression of human beings requires an environment in which they can be tested.
7. The environment would necessarily contain natural evil for the purpose of such testing.
8. The progression of human beings can only be achieved if they are significantly free.
9. The state of significantly free human beings necessitates the existence of moral good and moral evil.
C. Evil, both natural and moral, is the state of affairs created for and by the progression of human beings, on their path to the best possible world.

It is evident in this argument that evil is necessary in the process to achieving the best possible world. It does not only account for the evil in the world, but if it is taken one step further, one can begin to see the theme of opposition that is so often portrayed in scriptural text. For God to exist and create the best possible world, it was logically necessary for him to tolerate evil to test human beings to allow them to progress, and to be produced by human beings through their free-will.

Consider the story of Adams and Eve. This story is an illustration and explanation for the very process of soul-making and the concept of free-will. From the beginning, God commanded Adam and Eve not to eat the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge, but he did not forcefully restrict their access to it. After they have eaten of the fruit, God has the ability to forcefully restrict their access to the Tree of Life, representing it was within God’s power to do so. This command in contrast to forced restriction allows the reader to understand God’s affinity toward allowing significantly free humans. One must also take note that God allowed the influence of evil into the garden to tempt Adam and Eve. These two actions represent God’s allowance for significantly free humans and the necessity for temptation.

Once Adam and Eve partake of the fruit, choosing to progress instead of remaining in their “state of innocence and virtue” (3), God explains the path that they must take to progress in the direction of God. The Lord speaks to Adam and Eve and describes the necessities required in the process of this progression.

“Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children. . . And unto Adam he said. . . cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life; Thorns also and thistles shall it bring forth to thee; and thou shalt eat the herb of the field; In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” (4)

God also acknowledges the vital nature of opposition in this process of progression. “Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil.” (5) Adam and Eve’s expulsion from the Garden of Eden is a symbolic view of the epistemic distance that is required within soul making. This epistemic distance allows humans to develop, through the practice of using their free-will. The story of Adam and Eve exemplifies the idea that God created a world that is in the process of progression to the best possible world. It illustrates the necessity of natural evil and suffering for soul-making and the essential quality of free-will with all the positive and negative repercussions of it.

(1) John Hick, “The Starting Point”, Evil and the God of Love, (San Francisco: Harper and Row Publishers, 1977), 255.
(2) Ibid., 258.
(3) Ibid., 259.
(4) Genesis 3: 16-19
(5) Genesis 3: 22.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Philosophy of Religion Paper Part 1

A COOPERATION BETWEEN SOUL-MAKING AND FREE-WILL

“If the German people are already so corrupted and spiritually crushed that they do not raise a hand, frivolously trusting in a questionable faith in a lawful order in history; if they surrender man’s highest principle, that which raises him above all other God’s creatures, his free will. . .if they are so devoid of all individuality, have already gone so far along the road toward turning into a spiritless and cowardly mass – then, yes, they deserve their downfall.” (emphasis added)(1) Hans Scholl wrote these words in a leaflet in the summer of 1942. He was criticizing the acceptance of Hitler and his Nazi regime by the German people. Hans was a member of the group known as the White Rose resistance. This group stood against one of the greatest evils this world has ever seen in a manner that was both passive and brave. Their position was somewhat of an ironic stance because they stood against the evil of Hitler and his National Socialism on the grounds of freedom, specifically freedom condoned by God. It is that freedom, given by God, which allowed Hitler to commit the atrocities against a near innumerable amount of people. The existence of evil is often one of the most common criticisms of religious belief. The most solid defense against the problem of evil is a form of the free-will defense coupled with the soul-making theodicy.

Hitler is one of the greatest examples of the embodiment of evil. His policies led to the genocidal destruction of millions of people. The members of the White Rose were executed under his regime for professing the idea of freedom. The ironic nature to this is that their stance of, freedom condoned by God, is the stance that would be used in years to come to bring understanding to the problem that Hitler’s grave evils amassed against religious belief. It is understandable that someone would look at Hitler and the atrocities he committed and question the existence of God. It is only through the idea of freedom, or free-will, that the existence of God can be bolstered in the light of such great and obvious evil.

The problem of evil can be simply stated and seen in the connection of these four statements.
1. God is omnipotent.
2. God is omniscient.
3. God is omnibenevolent.
4. Evil exists.
These four statements do not seem as though they could all be true. If God is all powerful, all knowing, and wholly good, he would not have created a world where evil exists. It seems that because evil does exist that it would necessarily follow that God cannot exist in the form accepted by most Judeo-Christian traditions.

Before continuing on, the problem can be stated in another way that explains this argument in a more complete manner. This is J. L. Mackie’s take on the problem of evil.
1. If God exists, then God would be omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent.
2. An omnipotent being could bring about any logically possible world.
3. An omnibenevolent being would want to bring about the best possible world.
4. This is not the best possible world.
C. God does not exist.
To attack the conclusion of this argument, one would need to reject one of the premises. Premise number 1 is the definition of God accepted by most Judeo-Christian religions. Numbers 2 and 3 seem to follow logically from premise 1. Number 4 is the premise that is most easily open to attack, because it is an opinion that this is not the best possible world. In reality, one could easily flip premise number 4 and the conclusion and render a very different outcome. Leibniz does just that.
1. If God exists, then God would be omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent.
2. An omnipotent being could bring about any logically possible world.
3. An omnibenevolent being would want to bring about the best possible world.
4. God exists.
C. This is the best possible world.
The most logical response to the problem of evil would then come down one’s understanding of the best possible world.

Alvin Plantinga in his book, The Nature of Necessity, presents his version of the free-will defense. The goal of this defense is to show that there is a possible world that can include all four of the previously mentioned statements in relation to God and evil. His view looks to create a definition of the best possible world that is compatible with the discrepancy between God’s attributes and the presence of evil. His claim is that “a world containing creatures who are sometimes significantly free (and freely perform more good than evil actions) is more valuable, all else being equal, than a world containing no free creatures at all.”(2) To understand this claim the definition of significantly free must be addressed. The definition of a free person means that they have the ability to perform an action or refrain from performing an action. To be significantly free, the ability to choose must apply to situations that have a moral significance. It was not possible for God to create a world where people were significantly free without the having the option for both moral good and moral evil. If God were to have excised moral evil, it would not have been possible for the world to then have moral goodness.

The above point plays into the idea that there must be opposition in order to create a world where people are significantly free. The theory of opposition can be seen throughout religious texts. It begins with the story of creation. God created heaven and earth, darkness and light, dry land and water, etc. It is evident again in the story of Adam and Eve and their partaking of the tree of knowledge in which they begin to understand the nature of opposition. The idea of opposition reoccurs all throughout biblical text; Moses versus the Pharaoh, Lot versus his wife, Christ versus the criminals hanging on the crosses, the Good Samaritan versus those that passed by, etc. This theory of opposition in relation to the free will defense explains why moral evil exists in the world.

(1)White Rose, “The First Leaflet,” Inge Scholl, The White Rose, trans. Arthur R. Schultz (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1983), 73-74.

(2)Alvin Plantinga, “God, Evil, and Metaphysics of Freedom”, The Nature of Necessity, (New York: Oxford University Press, 1982), 166.

Term Papers In Parts

So the following posts will be parts of my term papers from this semester. I had a 10 pager in philosophy and a 15 pager in WWII. They took a lot of time and I am happy with how they turned out. These, other items of school work, and problems within the neighborhood are what have kept me occupied and unable to devote anytime to blogging. So here it goes, be prepared to be intellectually stimulated.