BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND TWITTER BACKGROUNDS »

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Eugenics, a side effect of national health care?

Maybe, how do you cut health care costs and provide it for everyone at that lower cost? I understand that the system is broken and needs fixing. I have been turned away from a pediatrician for a well baby check because I only had $300 in hand as opposed to the $500 they wanted as a safety net from those uninsured. Shortly after that I was blessed with a pediatrics group who still worked with the uninsured, and we loved them and always paid our bills in full.

Back to the topic in the title. One of my largest concerns is how we are going to afford nationalized health care as a nation, without drastic tax increases, insurmountable debt, or rising health care costs. If these are to be avoided the only possible solution is a rationing of the limited resources. It is basic supply and demand theory. We have seen this become an issue in almost every other nationalized health care system. The question than is, who is going to receive the resources as they are rationed based on basic supply and demand theory? Well, some of the white house officials have their plan for making these decisions.

Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel was appointed by President Obama as health-policy adviser at the Office of Management and Budget and a member of Federal Council on Comparative Effectiveness. He is one of the key advisers working to write the national health care plan. He has been cited in a number of reputable places as having an interesting and, in my opinion, scary view on health care allotment. In January of this year he co-wrote an article in the Lancet medical journal titled "Principles for allocation of scarce medical resources." It was written and published to help define guidelines in other countries with nationalized health care. I do not have an issue with someone expressing their opinion in an academic journal, what concerns me is the fact that he is a key adviser on the health care bills.

The government is notorious for underestimating the costs of their programs. They generally run 6 to 10 times over budget. If anything near this happened with the health care proposal we would be in an emergency quickly where tough choices would be made by a board of directors. The proponents say that their bills do not include anything that resembles Eugenics, addresses abortion, or will ration health care, but the truth is although those items are not specified, the control of defining health care in our country will be handed over to an appointed board of bureaucrats. This is what frightens me, because so far I have not been thrilled with the many of the bureaucrats Obama has appointed, beginning with Ezekiel Emanuel.

Ezekiel Emanuel looks at the way scarce resources should be allotted in a nationalized health care system. In the article in the Lancet journal on January 31, 2009, Emanuel supports a system known as the complete life system. It is based on aspects of the United Networks of Organ Sharing points, the Quality Adjusted Life Years, and Disability Adjusted Life Years systems. Here is a summary and outline of this system in his own written words.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
This system incorporates five principles: youngest first, prognosis, save the most lives, lottery, and instrumental value. . . When implemented, the complete lives system produces a priority curve on which individuals aged roughly between 15 and 40 get the most substantial chance, whereas the youngest and oldest people get chances that are attenuated. (pg 428)Ultimately, the complete lives system does not create "classes of Untermenschen whose lives and well being are deemed not worth spending money on", but rather empowers us to decide fairly whom to save. (pg 429)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Untermenschen - subhuman creatures - ironic that this plan of putting a statistical model in place to value life and allot health care resources is what will keep us human. I feel the opposite, tying a person to numbers and statistics makes them just that, a number or statistic, and strips away humanity in its purest form. It takes away empathy, compassion, charity, etc.

These are just a few overview lines out of entire article that tries to play God and assign worth to an individual based on a systematic formula. I am all about choice, and those decisions should be my choice, not that of some board, following some formula, set up by some know-it-all scholars. Other aspects of this system would take into account life worth not only based on age but on disability. The idea of instrumental value is defined as such in the article: "promoting and rewarding social usefulness based on the future" (pg 424). Between this and the age policies, I find myself feeling a little like this plan is a perfect way to promote Eugenics. Eugenics is defined as a science that deals with the improvement of hereditary qualities. On a historical note, it was a core tenet of Hitlers and the Nazi regime. If the right to medical care is placed in the sole discretion of the government, it creates an unbalanced system with very few checks. Many of you will argue that these bills are not looking for that kind of power but in what I have found, these bills are asking us to put a substantial amount of trust in a government and an appointed board. I do not trust the government enough to let them dictate my health care, especially after reading and hearing the thoughts and ideas of those that Obama has appointed so far. Here are just a few of those statements that cause me concern.
  • John Holdren, President's Assistant for Science and Technology - has advocated compulsory population control in America, including forced abortion and the addition of sterilizing agents to drinking water, and the creation of what he literally called a "Planetary Regime" that would enforce such a program worldwide. . ."Indeed, it has been concluded that compulsory population-control laws, even including laws requiring compulsory abortion, could be sustained under the existing Constitution if the population crisis became sufficiently severe to endanger the society. . . neither the Declaration of Independence nor the Constitution mentions a right to reproduce" (Ecoscience: Population, Resources, Environment, 837 - 838) - http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/jul/09071401.html
It is these kinds of stances and thoughts that scare me, especially as a history major who has seen the effects of eugenics, zero population, and master race philosophies. Zero population and eugenics tear at the very foundation of my core beliefs and it makes me nervous to see men with these viewpoints helping direct the discussion and form the bills that will be the foundation of our health care reform. I am sure these men are good people, but their views on humanity and health care leave a lot to be desired. I hope this has been informative and I ask you to really look at what has been said. I am sure I will have many more posts on the health care system. It definitely needs to be reformed, I just don't think that handing most of the control over to the government is going to fix it in the best way.

Please let me know if you would like me to e-mail you a copy of the article in the Lancet journal. It is a very interesting read. It is a PDF file I received through inter-library loan. The book by John Holdren was found in my university's library.

0 comments: